Theodicy: Why Is there Evil if God Is Good?   

How can evil exist in the world if God is good?  Why is there good and evil in the creation? How could evil exist if the world was created by a good and all-powerful God? Two classical arguments have been used to answer this question. 

Theodicy of Free Will 

God created a world of unspoiled harmony, beauty, and order at the beginning of time. Evil is introduced by the free acts of the spiritual beings whom God created – and so evil is the disorder that consequently infects the entire universe. The bad angels and the first human couple misused the gift of freedom bestowed upon them by God. 

The theodicy (or cosmology) of free will is usually traced back to the theology of Augustine of Hippo. However, the evolutionary theory has impacted this understanding. Nevertheless, the belief that evil has its source in man’s free deviation from God’s will (a deviation for which man alone is responsible) still influences many theologians.  

Augustine does not offer a good reason why some angels cleaved to the good and others did not if all were initially created in the same state of perfection and happiness. Karl Rahner, a modern theologian influenced by Augustine, was also forced to abandon the theodicy of free will as an adequate response of Christian faith to the understanding of evil. 

Theodicy of Development 

God creates the world not all at once, but over a long period of time. His creative work will be complete only when time ends and an eternal state of intimate communion between men and God is permanently established. Evil is linked to the incomplete character of the created order as it evolves. 

The way of justifying God’s goodness and power in the light of evil is to describe the positive role it can play in leading to salvation and how its sting is diminished by the nature of that end. God ordains evil as well as the good but never independently of the good – the evil serves the good. The logic behind such a paradoxical position is developmental – man must grow into God-consciousness. In sum, sin and evil are not only permitted but ordained by God – the consciousness of sin serves the development of the consciousness of God. 

Two theologians who exemplify this thinking are Friedrich Schleiermacher and Teilhard de Chardin. 

Criticism of the Two Classical Theodicies 

Both the theodicy of free will and theodicy of development have logical difficulties and ambiguities – despite the profundity of their insights and their usefulness in understanding freedom, human initiative, and cosmic development. They seem only to move the problem back one step further or to obscure deeper issues at stake. 

Source: Notes are either copied from or based on Michael Galligan, God and Evil (New York: Paulist Press, 1976), 17-37.